Compare the solutions for using disposable and fixed materials in a cleanroom environment.

Comparison of Single-use and Permanent Material Transfer Solutions in Cleanroom Environments

Speed or Sustainability

In pharmaceutical and biopharmaceutical manufacturing, transferring materials between cleanroom areas is an essential operation. There are two common methods:

• Single-use transfer solution uses disposable bags or tubes, ensuring sterility and preventing cross-contamination.
• Permanent transfer solution uses unchanging material transfer systems, such as steel pipes or static ports, requiring periodic cleaning and validation.

Each choice has its own advantages, depending on production objectives and operating costs.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Each Solution

Advantages of Single-use

• Fast and flexible: No cleaning required, reducing waiting time and accelerating production.
• Reduced cross-contamination risk: Using new, sterile materials each time helps optimize biological control.
• Resource savings: Avoids costly CIP/SIP (clean-in-place/steam-in-place) procedures that consume cost, energy, and water.

Limitations of Single-use

• High consumable costs: Requires continuous purchase of consumable materials, which may affect long-term costs.
• Waste generation: Packaging and single-use materials create large amounts of waste that need processing and recycling.

Advantages of Permanent Transfer

• Does not generate much waste: Fixed systems have long lifespans, reducing frequency of reinvestment costs and waste.
• Sustainable production process: Does not generate consumption of single-use raw materials.

Disadvantages of Permanent Transfer

• Time-consuming for CIP/SIP: Cleaning and validation processes are time-consuming, especially for high volume production or frequent product changes.
• Lack of flexibility: Difficult to adjust quickly when changing formulas or production lines.

Smart Combination Capability

Many manufacturing facilities choose solutions that combine both models:

• Use fixed pipelines for common raw and auxiliary materials.
• Use single-use for special materials or those prone to cross-contamination.

A typical example is the AdvantaPass® system, which allows sterile liquid transfer through cleanroom walls using single-use connectors, eliminating the need to clean fixed pipelines.

When to Use Each Solution?

Conclusion

There is no "one-size-fits-all" solution. Choosing a material transfer system in cleanrooms needs to be based on:

• Required sterility level
• Flexibility and production speed
• Ability to handle costs and waste disposal in the long term

Applying a flexible combination strategy between single-use and permanent transfer will optimize efficiency, save costs, and meet high requirements for safety and operation.

ANH KHANG CLEANROOM MECHANICAL & ELECTRICAL JOINT STOCK COMPANY Hotline: 1900 636 814 - 0902 051 222 Email: info@akme.com.vn Website: akme.com.vn Add: Lot B7 - Xuan Phuong Garden - Phuong Canh - Nam Tu Liem - Ha Noi.